My name is John Shea. I run an online blog called No Shame Income. I got started in the online marketing space around 2012 after seeing someone on Facebook talk about making money online with a blog.
I was compelled by the idea of making money on the internet and was determined to figure it out.
I spent years jumping from one thing to another trying all kinds of things to find success online. Something that took me years to figure out was that I wasn't going to make any money by constantly buying other people's products.
I realized that it seemed like everyone making income online was also selling something.
My No Shame Income blog is currently my home base where people can keep up to date with what I'm working on to make a living online.
One source of income is from selling online courses and creating products that help solve specific problems, though I also work with local businesses to help them with marketing services such as SEO or web design.
For my first year as an online marketer I used a terrible blog under my own name just to publish content. I eventually started a podcast over at VoicesOfMarketing.com and did this for roughly two years.
After having a hard time monetizing my podcast and ultimately not wanting to pursue it any further I decided I wanted to start a new blog with a bolder name.
A friend of mine I've known since middle school always would claim that I have no shame — think Frank in the TV show Shameless.
I typically don't come off this way to people online, but in my personal life I'm very brutally honest with everyone. Because of this I typically come across as this really blunt honest guy who does not seem to care much about what I say or do.
I thought the online space could use a bit of this. I was sick and tired of seeing all the sales pages out there with glorious testimonials about how awesome a product was when in reality a lot of stuff out there is garbage.
No one was willing to admit this, so I thought my No Shame Income blog would be a good approach to being honest about my success and my failures online.
You don't really see the true struggle and depression people go through as online entrepreneurs. People tend to only either be having massive success or simply very little if at all.
I wanted to show my true self through my blog and share the good and the bad: if I made $10,000 one month and $2,000 the next, I didn't want to be afraid to share that with people.
I've had a lot of ups and downs as an entrepreneur. I spent thousands of dollars on courses and programs, in some cases mentoring, and had mixed results.
I constantly found myself justifying why this next course purchase would be the answer.
I believe the biggest change I've had to make and still work on today, is that I had to change my mindset about how I approach success.
It's very common to buy a product, take some action and quickly give up because you don't get results quickly enough. I was constantly looking for a better way when in reality everything you do takes time in this space.
Some things may work better than others, but ultimately I just wanted to find something that:
My first breakthrough was in 2014 when I'd been working on a niche site all about skull-related clothing and accessories called SkullClothing.net
I had this sort of realization one Thursday at my day job that I could create a course all about how I'd built the site along with the steps I'd taken to do it.
That day I mapped out the syllabus, and by Sunday of that weekend I had the entire six-week course filmed and completed.
I published the course on a platform called Udemy where online courses are sold in a marketplace.
This happened in early November of 2014, so with Black Friday being the biggest time of the year I managed to earn over $850 in sales through their marketplace without any of my own marketing from the course.
I was hooked and decided to keep going with courses. Today I have over 40 courses and over 70,000 students on Udemy.
This was no overnight task, but creating online courses was something I became more and more passionate about doing.
Today I've earned over $36k from Udemy, over $20k on Skillshare and another $30k+ from selling through my own website.
For the first year I didn't do much with the blog. I've always felt like I wasn't that good at generating traffic, and honestly I still feel that way.
Most of the visitors come through my email list which I built from product and course sales. I've also written quite a number of product reviews for my site. This has allowed me to rank some articles on Google and get monthly traffic from that.
Since my blog itself has not been the major component of growing my audience, I'll share what has worked for me:
Partnerships
I've found seeking out the right people to work with can be huge for building an email list, launching products, and making an income online.
One example is how I created a course sharing how I achieved all of my success with Udemy and Skillshare.
Years before, while doing my podcast, I'd met my now long-time friend Mike Thomas, who runs an interview show called Mike From Maine. He interviews product creators nearly every day and promotes their products as an affiliate.
I approached Mike with my idea and showed him the success I was having with courses, so we decided to package it up and sell this story as a product.
Sharing all the details of doing this would be another course in and of itself, but the general approach was:
We launched Video Course Cash Kit with the help of my girlfriend (she gave a testimonial of being a total newbie following this course and making sales) and the entire launch did $58,000, split between Mike, Brett, and myself.
From this we had over 1,000 buyers, which I was able to add to my email list and in turn promote more products to as I saw fit.
A great place to seek out partners is by looking around on the internet marketing forums.
I also highly recommend approaching people with a personal video to introduce yourself. You'll stand out from everyone else by doing this.
When people ask me this question I just tell them "I create and sell online courses"
Despite putting a lot of energy into this over the past year, I've been struggling to do it through my own site, but I'm still learning and I'm not giving up on it.
Typically the other ways I make money are by promoting other products as an affiliate or doing local marketing with businesses to help them rank on Google. These both make good money, but ultimately my passion is in creating and selling courses.
Right now I'm using a combination of Active Campaign and Clickfunnels to segment my email list, get people interested in what I'm teaching, and then sell them a high-end product they can find success with.
My current primary focus is selling a course all about how to start an SEO consulting business.
One of the other ways I've made good income online over the years is by creating websites and helping businesses with SEO. I've earned somewhere north of $50k doing this part time, and it's one of the best ways to build a real business.
You can check out my in-depth article on how I approach this model now with the clients I work with.
Today I'm earning anywhere from $5-10k/month from a combination of both models.
Right now my biggest goal is to pay off my house. In my world this is sort of like my ultimate goal so I can have more freedom to take risks with my money. And quite simply, I plan to do this by working with more clients and selling more courses.
Ultimately it's not so much about the money for me but being able to do what I want when I want.
Probably for me it's always been focus. This is an area people constantly tell me I need to improve: trying to do too many things at once and never really becoming a master in one specific thing.
It's always been a challenge with all the new shiny objects, courses, and potential ways to make money online.
I share a much longer version of my personal story and all the struggles I've faced over the years in this post here.
It's a long read (almost like a short book in and of itself) but you will learn from my years of mistakes how I got to my position today.
If I were to do things differently I would have started teaching people something I was good at sooner and focused on just getting really good in that one area.
I use a to-do platform called Nozbe to track my daily goals and keep myself accountable for what I'm working on.
I've also had great success getting a lot more done when I did a 30-day Ddiscipline challenge. You can follow the journey I had with this here.
I'm just going to leave my top two tips.
You can head over to my blog No Shame Income or find me on Facebook.
And if you want to learn more about my client SEO success be sure to grab my eBook on how I landed my first client.
Thanks for the post.I just want to know whether you upload the same course in both Udemy and Skillshare,or do you upload different kinds of courses in each of them. Im familiar with udemy but,don't know how skillshare works.
Typically I do, although more recently most of my course work I'm publishing on my own site and charging more for.
Skillshare is a monthly fee.
I don't mean to sound too harsh, but based on your story, you're everything that's wrong with our industry (SEO/PPC).
It seems you took a long journey down the wrong path of MLM and MMO schemes, and the only success you've had is selling things you're not qualified to sell. Why would you take on SEO/Marketing clients, if you've failed to do your own SEO/Market your own shit?
I have no doubt that you've learned a lot along the way, but the fact that the first significant money you've managed to make has come from doing work you're unqualified to do (SEO) and teaching others "how to make money online" is terrible.
Not knocking you for making $6k/m, that's "ok" money, but in your monthly income reports you clearly show that you're making money selling MMO tools, courses, and that you're outsourcing SEO for your clients, which probably means you're buying backlinks...
Best of luck to you, man, but I don't really like the route you're taking.
So...
In some ways you are right but as someone who has not actually seen or done everything I've done over the years I can't agree 100%
I have ranked my own sites content through a couple niche sites I have and many client sites over the years in the local map pack, mostly from a lot of my own trial and error. I just realized I don't particularly like the technical side of SEO, I just like the idea of ranking on Google.
I'm much better at sales and communication overall. I realized after working at this whole "SEO" thing for a while the people who make money are simply just good at sales.
I learned enough that I know what I'm doing to get results, I'd rather just pay someone else to do the work and focus on sales/clients vs. doing everything on my own.
I think what I'm not conveying in my story and income reports, is I haven't "failed" to rank my own content.. I simply just tried it, had some success and realized I don't like doing it.
I worked for an agency for 8 months where the owner charged clients $1000-1500/m for doing SEO/Adwords and the "SEO" was having an in-house writer publish 4 articles a month with zero SEO optimization, zero backlinks and simply sharing them to social media.
I know way more about SEO than the owner and all the employees there when of course here I was thinking I'd be coming into a role to see an in-house team doing all kinds of cool stuff.
But nope, that was 100% not the case. He was good at Adwords and ultimately just a really good sales guy.
This honestly pushed me more to the outsourcing path because I saw how much opportunity there was to do more on the sales side of things.
Plus I can actually get clients results using the right service providers.
In terms of the "not being qualified" remark I used to think that too, for a while it stopped me from even trying.
I suggest you go watch the movie "Catch Me If You Can" and realize that all you need to do is be one step ahead of anyone you are teaching in order to show someone else.
If my stuff sucked so bad I wouldn't have thousands of Udemy reviews and pages like this filled with positive testimonials:
http://www.noshameincome.com/vault
I sense some some jealously in your comment as well, I suggest reading "The Magic Of Thinking Big" you'll learn pretty quickly to stop being even remotely negative towards other's success despite how they got there or the path they took.
No jealousy, currently my affiliate site doing $300-400/day profit from organic SEO traffic and some adsense.
Client SEO work is at $13,750, lowest paying client is $3,250... avg client has 50 employees, does $10m a year... so I'm doing work for real companies that you've heard of.
You are doing really well then, congrats.
I absolutely agree.
I mean it feels strange: you are selling your audience on topics about "how to make money", while in reality you are just doing so by telling them.
So essentially you are saying "hey, look how I made $6,000 this month selling you courses on how I made $5,000 last month".
To me this is a somewhat strange business model. You make money telling other people how they eventually can, so you are not really a coach or expert in a specific topic or skill, but rather selling an audience on their hopes and wishes of making money.
Good for you that you make a pretty good chunk with that now and all the best, but I can just agree with anthmye in all points.
Part of what your not seeing is I've also made a lot of money doing the things I'm teaching. As of 2017 I focused a lot more on the "teaching" itself vs. doing those things I've had success at.
Something I also realized is in this industry that is how a LARGE number of people have success, simply selling and creating products.
I look at it like if I made $50 doing something on my own... that's something I can teach to someone else.. can I make more than $50 teaching it?
You bet.. I'll do that all day long and so will 100% of the people pushing products on http://www.jvzoo.com and http://www.warriorplus.com everyday.
I'm actually surprised/disappointed that indiehackers would even approve this garbage...
I think this comment is overly harsh, and TheFox's comment is somewhat inaccurate. While John is clearly not a top 1% world-class expert at SEO, marketing, courses, etc., he's still providing value to people via his courses on Udemy and generating revenue as a result.
It's admittedly not sexy stuff: how to find clients on Fiverr, how to make a WordPress store, how to optimize your Google Business page, etc. But it's helpful to some people. Similarly his Video Course Cash Kit may look a bit like one of those gross long-form sales pages to you and me… but he's selling people a $50 course with a guarantee that they can make $100 on Udemy. Again, maybe not all that sexy, but certainly not sleazy. It's unfair to label it "garbage." I'm sure it's eye-opening and useful information to a lot of people.
All that said, if you're worried about Indie Hackers sliding down a slippery slope to becoming a dumping ground for cheap marketing schemes, you don't have to worry. We've been getting a lot of submissions for those from day one, and I like to think we're pretty good at drawing a line. I definitely appreciate your feedback, and let's also try to keep things constructive and civil!
Agree to disagree.
He clearly admits in his income reports that he sells backlinks on Fatjoe, and that he also buys backlinks from services like Fatjoe and The Hoth. In fact, he has a review of the hoth here (because he'll earn a comission for recommending shit blackhat services)
http://www.noshameincome.com/product-reviews/the-hoth-review-2017/
I gathered that from 5-10 minutes of skimming his site.
Nobody who is even remotely good at SEO would take someone serious who uses services like "The Hoth". It's buying backlinks by proxy, nothing more than a crappy PBN/link network.
He also admits that his "clients" are local, small businesses that he's had success ranking in the "map pack".
So, you're right he's not a top 1% SEO expert, not even close.
It's worrisome that he's willing to take money from small businesses, who very well may not have that much extra money to invest into their businesses, buy links on their behalf, knowing that it's against Google's rules.
But, it's enough to even temporarily gather some small wins, coin himself an "SEO expert", and sell some courses to newbies about how they too can rank their sites and/or take on clients.
I have nothing against someone who sells courses/services, if they are truly qualified to do so.
The fact he's buying links (and selling links on his own sites for as little as $50) tells me he's just trying to make a quick buck, he doesn't care if he puts his "clients" at risk, he just wants to gather some rankings so he has screenshots to prove he knows what he's doing, and use it to sell his courses where he gives shitty advice.
Per the Indie Hackers "Contribution" page you say agencies or non-scaleable businesses are not accepted for interviews. I think that's a fantastic policy. I hate agencies for 2 reasons... 1. they're not very scalable and 2. They tend to be professional invoicers, they justify a huge bill every month, but didn't actually deliver nearly the value they are charging for.
The only thing worse, in my opinion, is a small/local agency. At least the big agencies are billing huge companies that can afford to foot the bill... small SEO agencies are the worst, they'll send an invoice for $1,500 and say "Congratulations, we ranked you #1 for [best hair restoratoin service in san diego california on the west side of the street, that operates between the hours of 8am and 7pm during monday through friday and every other saturday]
... meaning they'll rank you for some "long tail" keyword nobody actually searches, and when you bring that up, they'll justify it by saying "Yes, but if just 1 person converts, it covers your SEO bill for 3 months!".
So, tl;dr - John isn't qualified to sell SEO services or courses. He buys and sells links. John takes on small, local SEO clients, he's doing more harm than help. John's business is only scalable because he takes his small wins, turns them into a course, and sells it.
Again, I may sound harsh, but if you can't agree that buying/selling links is a bad practice, and that anyone willing to do is only looking to make money and shouldn't be selling SEO services/courses, then I'm not sure there's any convincing you.
Would you be willing to buy links or sell links on Indiehackers?
Ahh.. this makes a bit more sense why you were so upset about all this.
While I did review FatJoe and The Hoth I don't currently use either of them for my own link building efforts.
Yes I am a publisher on one of my sites for Fatjoe but it's a very real website that is my own I built over 4-5+ years (no PBN or anything of that nature)
I have used PBN's in the past before all the big de-indexing occured and don't currently use those for my clients sites either.
Right now I use actual whitelabel firms that I've built relationships with that have actual in-house employees doing all the work.
I am simply a middle man, I get my clients results using a team of people who do proven whitehat link building techniques.
But at the same time I handle 100% of the communication, reporting, plus any client concerns and the clients are happy with the results.
Given that you've never taken one of my courses saying I'm "not qualified" is quite a bold statement.
In fact In my main course I focus a lot more on things like using systems, getting clients, communicating with clients, invoicing, finding partners etc. vs. all the technical stuff you are referring to.
Honestly you are being overly critical about all of this, look at BlackHatworld.com forum sales and all the other course creators pushing PBN's and the like..
Your acting like I'm this big bad "Black Hat" SEO when that's not the case what so ever.
Yeah, I agree with most of what you have to say. I'm not endorsing his SEO services or defending their quality. I realize as an SEO yourself you feel strongly about this, but I'd prefer that the level of discussion remain higher than name-calling ("this garbage"). Detailed criticisms like this comment and most of your other comments are more than welcome.
I understand. I apologize if I came across as a jerk, wasn't my intention. I just have a sore spot for these sorts of things. .. I've been doing SEO for 10 years and when I see things like this I cringe.
I don't like seeing courses that teach complete newbies to "start their own digital marketing agency".
My best friend paid $1,000 for Tai Lopez course that teaches you how to start a seo/ppc/social media marketing agency and take on small businesses as clients.
My best friend can barely turn on his laptop, and now he's telling me how he's going out and getting marketing clients... and that's the case for most people who buy into this stuff.
The end result is a bunch of unqualified people, whose only goal is to make money, selling marketing services, taking money from small businesses who usually can't afford it, not providing real value, and in the end it damages an industry I am very passionate about (SEO and PPC) which already has a bad reputation.
I'm working with a handful of SaaS companies, like I mentioned in a previous comment most of them have about ~50 employees. I don't do any contracts, and I have clients who have been with me 2 years. My philosophy is "if you pay me $3,000/month for my services, you should be getting AT LEAST $3,000/month worth of value" (leads, business, pipeline, etc.) If you don't feel like my services were worth it, I don't want your money.
The problem with a lot of agencies, is that they are completely fine overbilling for services... they get a bunch of contracts, hand it off to recent marketing grads, or outsource it, collect some checks for 2-3 months, and eventually upset the customer and they churn.
This is a stressful (and unethical) way to run a business if you ask me. I can't sleep at night taking money from people who I know I'm not providing value to.
Yeah, I know this same kind of people.
I literally know "entrepreneurs" who watched a handful of YouTube videos and now walk around charging dentists 2k a month for some random advertising.
Doesn't work? Well, at least you got 1 month (or half a month) of salary then and can move on.
This is just a really, REALLY bad way to do business.
Like anthmye I'm deeply involved in PPC (not SEO) and work with highly reputable, international clients. I don't have anything against people doing marketing for local businesses or anything like that.
What bothers me is that nowadays everyone calls himself "marketing consultant" and "internet entrepreneur", providing entry-level value at high-end-level prices.
"As long as they buy it, why should you care?" - well, there is something called FALSE ADVERTISING. If you tell someone upfront "hey, let me be your FB Marketer, I'm not a professional but I'll do my best and if it works out you can pay me" that's entirely fine.
If you just took a 2-hour online course, call yourself "leading PPC expert" and charge a fat retainer for your intern-level knowledge, then realizing that you can't provide any value anyway, that's much closer to a scammer than a "business owner".
//same goes for "agencies" that have entry-level knowledge and just outsource any jobs the moment they get them to random people on Fiverr and Upwork. I literally worked with such an "agency" before - they took any client willing to pay, found a freelancer and gave him the job. If he didn't complete it successfully they were just leaving a bad review for the freelancer and apologizing. That's not how you run a business.
I've got an idea... I am remodeling my kitchen this month, so far I've watched about 20 videos and hanging cabinets and installing backsplash looks pretty easy.
Want to start a kitchen remodeling business with me? :)
Better yet, let's teach people how to remodel their kitchens, and then teach them how to start a kitchen remodeling business, show them how they can go out and charge $20k average for kitchen remodels.
Best of luck to these type of people selling crap like this.
P.S. My affiliate site hit a ATH of $806 yesterday, pure profit from organic SEO traffic - Feels good to make that sort of money without teaching people "how to make money".
So here would be a solution for you, and a positive way for you to actually do something that would help others who are getting started.
Why don't you let me interview you about your success with your clients and I'll publish it on my blog and share it with my students?
I've interviewed around 7-8 other 6-7 figure agency owners and everyone has something different to share, they all run business differently as well.
Some guy's work from home with 10 employees, others have 50+ employees and work in-house, some sold their agencies.
I'd say just start looking at how you can contribute something positive to those who do want to learn.
The other thing I'd say is everyone needs to start somewhere, I've improved my course over time after working for myself AND working for a 7 figure agency as an employee and seeing the day to day operations.
You are bummed about people buying links, this agency sold $1500-2000 packages the "SEO" was having a writer publish 4-8 blog articles a month with zero on-page optimization and zero link building efforts.
The owner knew nothing about SEO and legit told me he "didn't know you could manipulate map pack rankings" when I first got employed there.
So, yes there are people/agencies out there not providing the value you speak of.
Anyway, email me if you'd like and I'd gladly let you voice your feedback/opinions to my audience on doing it the right way.