Ping He built four products totaling about $255k/mo in revenue.
I caught up with him to learn how he did it. Turns out, his first success happened because he ignored traditional indie hacking wisdom. And his biggest success happened because he positioned himself as a first mover in AI, even though he wasn't using AI.
Here's what he had to say. 👇
James: How did you get started?
Ping: There was no entrepreneurship culture in my family growing up, but I spent a summer with my uncle during high school. He’s a street vendor who travels and sells random things.
I remember liking the freedom that he enjoyed.
James: Did you become an entrepreneur right away?
Ping: No, in 2009, I was in Silicon Valley working in the semiconductor industry. I decided that I wanted to build a side project, so I started with an e-commerce website.
I needed a logo. And I became really impressed with the logo contests at 99designs.
James: So you started a competitor?
Ping: Yes, I started a logo contest website called 48hourslogo.
It’s important to build products that scratch your own itch. I’ve done that with all my businesses.
James: And you were okay with going up against a big competitor like that?
Ping: I like to innovate in existing markets.
James: Why?
Ping: You know exactly who your customers are and what search keywords you should target to find them.
James: How did you compete?
Ping: I targeted the niche keyword, "logo contest", to find customers. And then I differentiated by setting the contest starting price at half the price of 99designs.
James: Some say competing on price is a "race to the bottom".
Ping: I didn't think too much about that at the time. I simply felt that I would have been more than happy to pay half the price and get half the design options when I used 99designs.
James: Where is 48hourslogo at now?
Ping: It’s at $100k/mo.
James: What happened next?
Ping: As that grew, I noticed that a lot of “custom logo designs" were basically the same templates being used over and over again by the designers. So I started LogoAI to automate the logo creation process.
James: And how’s that doing?
Ping: It’s at $150k/mo.
James: When did you start it?
Ping: In 2018.
James: So you were building AI products before it was cool.
Ping: Well, not really. “AI” was just marketing.
James: How so?
Ping: After running 48hourslogo for several years, I was pretty familiar with logo design, and I knew this would be the next step — replacing human designers with AI.
But there was no AI back then, so I generated the designs from templates.
James: So the name was more of a goal than a reality at the time.
Ping: Essentially. And I’ll say that I got lucky with the LogoAI domain name.
Subscribe for more how-tos, roundtables, and interviews with people in the thick of it.
James: Are you working on anything else?
Ping: Recently, I've been working on uBrand — an AI-assisted branding platform for entrepreneurs. It’s at $5k MRR.
James: It sounds like each of these has a different model.
Ping: 48hourslogo is a traditional marketplace business model. LogoAI is a usage-based model. uBrand is a SaaS model.
James: And you run this $255k/mo portfolio on your own?
Ping: I never brought on any partners or investors because it started as a side project and grew quickly. But I have a small team of eight people.
James: What's your day-to-day like?
Ping: In the morning, I work on the routine tasks such as answering support emails in my home office.
I meet my team members in our coworking office around 2pm on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays to talk about the projects they are working on and brainstorm new ideas. We have a super efficient team because we have been working together for years.
James: Why not have your team handle the support?
Ping: I like to keep tabs on the support emails because I get lots of product improvement ideas from them.
James: Let’s talk about growth.
Ping: Indie hackers tend to spend more time building than marketing.
James: True. And you?
Ping: My rule is to split my time and effort 50/50.
James: Where do you focus your marketing time?
Ping: I’ve grown my businesses mostly via organic SEO. It’s a core expertise of mine.
James: Is SEO still a good bet for indie hackers?
Ping: Absolutely. I think founders spend too much time on Product Hunt launches and not enough time on SEO.
I’m such an SEO advocate that I even launched linktopia.io — a link-building community for SaaS founders.
James: How's that doing?
Ping: It went online about a week ago and I got my first paid customer yesterday.
James: Congrats! So what’s your SEO process?
Ping: I'd recommend the following three basic steps to set up your website for SEO success:
Research the keywords that you want to target and work them into your webpage titles.
Set Up a blog to write about related topics and create internal links.
Get backlinks. I like to get them from other founders, hence Linktopia.
James: Simple enough. Has SEO changed since you started?
Ping: Not really… But I don't keep track of any so-called Google algorithm updates.
James: Why not?
Ping: I don't try to beat Google. It’s better to simply tell Google about the product or service you provide with convincing landing pages and then mention them (via backlinks) whenever you have a chance.
James: Do you have any other SEO tips for us?
Ping: Research the keywords related to your product or service before building your product.
James: Smart. Did anything else help you grow?
Ping: One thing that worked really well was incentivizing customers to share their logo designs.
James: How did you incentivize that?
Ping: I gave them the design for free if they got 20 likes.
I also do a lot of organic marketing by simply creating profiles on websites like IH and commenting on posts related to my product.
It’s important to leave mentions of your website because Google will pick up these traces and your search results will improve.
James: Makes sense
Ping: But my main advice is this: Don't always take the shortcut.
James: What’s wrong with shortcuts?
Ping: Indie hackers and solopreneurs have limited bandwidth, so focusing on short-term gains is tempting. But it saves time in the long run to focus on long-term, cumulative results.
James: Any final nuggets of indie hacking wisdom before we wrap up?
Ping: Build an MVP.
I don't like the idea of validating a potential market with a survey or just a landing page like so many people are suggesting.
James: Why not?
Ping: It doesn’t capture the user’s true intentions. The information they see is too limited.
Instead, just build and launch the MVP. You will learn a lot more during the building process than you will from empty responses from a survey.
James: Where can people find you?
Ping: Check out Linktopia if you want to up your SEO game. My other products are LogoAI, uBrand, and 48hourslogo.
This is amazing! My goal at the moment is to just build something people want to use. I've always had this deep desire to make something someone finds useful, but with work and family demands it's hard to stay focused and get a project over the finish line.
I'm with you Matt!
Ping this is an amazing story and incredible success in the thought space of logo design with so much competition.. good stuff..
From Germany, good morning to all of you. I would like to take this opportunity to quickly share my experience with Space Spy Recovery and to urge you all to check them out. I run a jewelry store in my nation, and none of it would be possible now if Space Spy Recovery hadn't helped me retrieve 940,000 Euros that a fraudster had taken from me using Bitcoin. I'm glad these incredible tech experts saved me from losing everything. If you require expert support, you should get in touch with them by using: Telegram: @spacespy65,
Thanks, Ping and James, nice story. I clicked on the backlinks to up your SEO:).
What does it mean to research keywords, exactly?
Growing such a portfolio of products is very much impressive and proves just how much marketing is important in the role of building a product/service. I'm just glad to learn about how important marketing is. Will follow the 50/50 rule!
Couldn't agree more - MVPs are key.
That's sick money!
I feel SEO is a great choice, and I'm trying to give it a try with programmatic SEO e.g.
[Screenshot Editor for Startups](https://startuputils.com/screenshot-editor-online-for-startups)
[Startup Logo Generator](https://startuputils.com/startup-logo-generator-for-side-projects)
[Open Graph Image Generator for side-projects](https://startuputils.com/startup-og-image-generator-online)
and already seeing some results. Basing your business marketing only on social media channels can be hard, with those changing algorithms.
For example on Twitter, with no audience and without the Pro version you'll end up in the void and get 1 like. Same with TikTok - got like 200 views, 0 redirects to the landing page.
sorry for broken URLs, I cannot edit the post not sure why :((
Lot of helpful nuggets in here
It's given me some ideas of my own. Thanks for sharing !
Ping He's entrepreneurial journey thrived by innovating within established markets and pioneering in AI. Despite lacking actual AI, he leveraged templates creatively. This strategy propelled his businesses, including 48hourslogo and LogoAI, to substantial revenue, showcasing the power of unconventional approaches in entrepreneurship and marketing.
I am also struggling with the SEO and built my website. I am also providing local SEO services as a freelancer.
Thank you for sharing i'm loving this community
looking forward to posting my own startup stories once i acquire the permission
Thank you for sharing. Building even a minimal MVP is a crucial step.
Instant upvote! How did you manage to get in touch?
I like the 20 likes incentive. When you say likes, do you mean in your platform or in social media?
I am very happy to hear these sharings, which make me realize the importance of product innovation in the existing market, and MVP. This is awesome!
innovating on existing market is a very underrated. In fact I have wrote a post here about [Novelty is overrated, just copy what's working](https://www.indiehackers.com/post/novelty-is-overrated-just-copy-whats-working-df54e17d0d)
The idea of the article is you just need to improve on what already working because as indiehacker we unable to spend that much time or resources on educating customer.
So we can just ride on things already customer understand how to use but improve it to meet some specific needs
Fantastic story and insights!
Love this! Congrats on ur success!
Thanks for your insight. It shows that working on an organic SEO is an efficient use of time for continuous customer acquisition.
How do I ping Ping to learn more from him. :)
you can ping Ping on pingping.com
good
Ping is a very humble, laser-focused entrepreneur. He is working on a new product now called linktopia which provides start-up runners a platform to give links to receive links - and it's incredibly important for SEO!
Thanks @YuchengL
This is impressive. Completely agree with staying close to customer support as a way to improve the product.
Yep. If you don't know what to do next? Talk to your customers. 😊
Linktopia is absolutely genius wow.
Thank you Stephen. I wasn't going to start a new project but link building is so much pain and I finally decided to launch Linktopia.
Great discussion!
this is insane, this guy just generates crazy mrr!
Midas hands.
have you met Pieter Levels
Love this! Congrats on the success. Clearly you are doing something right if you have managed to get all four of your businesses to bring in revenue.
I have been building emailemu.com, but part of my struggle is finding paying customers early on. I have lots of people sign up daily and use the product, but converting user to pay is tougher.
Hi Wyatt,
Thanks and good job that you already have people signing up and use your product daily. Usually that's the hard part. Maybe you can try let people browse the first email from each brand for free and only a skeleton of the subsequent emails and that's when they need to upgrade.😝
Don't forget to add your blog to linktopia.io to start building your SEO traffic.
Thanks! That's a interesting idea may be worth looking into. I wonder if that would deter people from using it at all and if traffic to the site with free users actually would end up being more vauable in the long run. If I try for more of the ads angle.